Loading...
Viewing content for
Viewing content for

What makes a Will invalid in New South Wales? 

Francesca Zappia

Francesca Zappia

Lawyer |

New South Wales

Go back to the blog
Reviewing documents

Making a Will is one of the most important steps you can take to protect your loved ones and ensure your wishes are carried out after your death. But if a Will is not created using the proper procedures it can be found to be invalid.

A Will may be considered invalid in New South Wales if it was not properly signed and witnessed, the Will-maker lacked testamentary capacity, did not understand or approve its contents, or was subjected to undue influence, fraud or forgery.

If a Will is found to be invalid, it can result in costly disputes, delays in administering the estate and outcomes that the deceased person might not have intended.

In New South Wales, there are several reasons why a Will may be challenged or declared invalid. Understanding what can make a Will invalid is an important part of effective estate planning and can help avoid unnecessary disputes, delays and costs for your loved ones.

What are the grounds for invalidating a Will in NSW?

There are five primary reasons that can affect the validity of a Will:

  • If a Will does not comply with the formal signing and witnessing requirements under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).
  • If the Will-maker did not have testamentary capacity.
  • If the Will-maker did not understand and approve the contents of the Will.
  • If the Will was created through coercion, fraud or forgery.
  • Marriage, divorce and later Wills can affect whether an existing Will remains valid.

The Will was not properly signed and witnessed

For a Will to be valid, it must generally comply with the formal requirements set out in section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).

This means the Will must:

  • be in writing;
  • be signed by the Will-maker;
  • be signed or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses who are present at the same time; and
  • be signed by those witnesses in the presence of the Will-maker.

Problems with a Will’s validity often happen when only one witness signs the Will, the witnesses are not present at the same time, signatures are missing, or pages are added or replaced after the Will has been signed.

Also, if a beneficiary named in the Will, witnesses the Will, their entitlements might be invalidated pursuant to section 10 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).

Although the Supreme Court of New South Wales may, in some circumstances, recognise an informal document as a valid Will, this usually requires court proceedings and additional evidence. It is far safer, quicker and less expensive to ensure the Will is executed correctly from the outset.

The Will-maker lacked testamentary capacity

A person must have what is known as “testamentary capacity” when they make their Will.

Put simply, they must understand:

  • that they are making a Will;
  • the effect of making a Will;
  • the nature and extent of their assets; and
  • the people who may reasonably expect to benefit from their estate.

A Will can be challenged where there are concerns that the Will-maker was suffering from dementia, cognitive impairment, serious illness, delusions or another condition affecting their decision-making ability.

Importantly, a diagnosis of dementia does not automatically make a Will invalid. The key question is whether the person had sufficient capacity at the time they signed the Will.

In situations where capacity may be questioned, obtaining medical evidence and keeping detailed records of the Will-making process is very important.

The Will-maker did not understand or approve the Will

Even when a person has capacity and the Will has been properly signed, the Court must be satisfied that the Will-maker understood and approved the contents of the document.

Concerns about knowledge and approval can arise in a variety of circumstances, including:

  • the Will was prepared or arranged by a person who stands to benefit under it;
  • the Will-maker had impaired eyesight, literacy difficulties or was otherwise unable to independently review the document;
  • the Will-maker had limited English proficiency, and no interpreter was used to explain the Will;
  • another person provided instructions to the solicitor on the Will-maker’s behalf; or
  • the Will contains significant or unexpected changes from previous Wills, particularly where close family members have been excluded or their entitlements substantially reduced.

In these cases, additional evidence may be required to prove that the Will accurately reflects the Will-maker’s intentions. For this reason, solicitors generally insist on meeting directly with the Will-maker and carefully explaining the document before it is signed.

The Will was made under undue influence or coercion

A Will should reflect the genuine wishes of the person making it. If a person is pressured into making or changing their Will, the document may not be valid.

This issue is known as undue influence. It arises where a person’s free will is worn down by pressure, manipulation or coercion, until the Will reflects another person’s wishes rather than their own.

Examples may include:

  • a family member threatening to withdraw care, support or contact unless they are included in the Will;
  • a person isolating the Will-maker from family members or trusted advisers;
  • someone exerting persistent pressure on the Will-maker to change their Will for that person’s benefit; or
  • a vulnerable person becoming dependent on someone who then seeks to control their estate planning decisions.

Importantly, undue influence involves more than just persuasion. For a Will to be deemed invalid on this ground, there must be clear evidence that the Will-maker’s independent judgment was shifted and that the resulting Will does not reflect their own free and voluntary intentions.

The Will was created through fraud or forgery

A Will can also be invalid if it was obtained through fraud, deception or forgery. When the document has been obtained dishonestly or does not truly represent the wishes of the deceased, the Court may refuse to deem the document as valid.

Examples of conduct that may give rise to concerns include:

  • forging the Will-maker’s signature;
  • altering the contents of a Will after it has been signed;
  • deliberately misleading the Will-maker to influence how they distribute their estate; or
  • presenting a document as the deceased’s Will when it was never read, approved or authorised by them.

Can a Will be revoked in NSW?

A Will that was valid when signed may later become ineffective if it is revoked. A Will can be revoked in several ways, including:

  • making a new Will;
  • signing a document that expressly revokes the earlier Will; or
  • destroying the Will with the intention of revoking it.

In some circumstances, significant life events can also affect the operation of a Will. For example, marriage will generally revoke an existing Will unless it was specifically made in contemplation of that marriage. Conversely, while divorce does not revoke the entire Will, it will generally revoke gifts made to a former spouse and any appointment of that former spouse as executor, trustee or guardian.

What happens if a Will is found invalid?

If a Will is found to be invalid, the deceased person’s estate will not remain undistributed. Instead, the law provides a framework for determining how the estate is to be administered and who is entitled to inherit.

In most cases, the estate will be distributed in accordance with the most recent valid Will. However, if there is no earlier valid Will, the estate will be administered under the intestacy provisions of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW).

This can produce outcomes that are very different from those the deceased intended. For example, beneficiaries named in the invalid Will may receive no benefit at all, while family members entitled under the intestacy rules may inherit instead. In some cases, close friends, stepchildren, charities and other intended beneficiaries may be excluded because they do not fall within the categories of persons entitled to inherit according to intestacy laws.

For this reason, ensuring that your Will is validly prepared and executed is an important part of effective estate planning.

How can you prevent a Will from being invalid?

While no Will is completely immune from challenge, there are several practical steps that can significantly reduce the risk of disputes and help ensure that your wishes are carried out after your death.

These include:

  • obtaining independent legal advice when preparing or updating your Will;
  • providing instructions directly to your solicitor, rather than through a family member or other third party;
  • ensuring your Will is properly signed and witnessed in accordance with the legal requirements;
  • reviewing your Will regularly, particularly after major life events such as marriage, divorce, the birth of children or significant changes in your financial circumstances;
  • obtaining medical evidence where there may be concerns about capacity when creating a Will; and
  • keeping the original Will in a secure location and ensuring your executor knows where it is stored.

If you have concerns about the validity of a Will or wish to prepare or update your estate planning documents, get in contact with one of our Wills and Estates teams. We have Wills & Estate teams in NSW, QLD and SA.

This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for legal advice. Laws and legal processes may differ between states, and your individual circumstances may affect how the information applies to you. Contact our team for advice relevant to your circumstances.

No win, no fee* on all compensation claims

Learn more

Talk to our team

Complete the form and a member of our team will get in touch with you soon.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*

How to contact us

Our team is ready to help

Phone

Mon-Fri from 8am-5pm

13 43 63

Email

Our friendly team is here to help

enquiries@turnerfreeman.com.au

Live Chat

Chat with a team member